Why Not a Square Tree?

Experiment

by on ; last featured March 12, 2017
Share:

Some realities of nature are so common that we don’t even stop to ask why. Like round trees.

Why don’t we find square tree trunks or triangular shapes in nature? Many obvious details, such as round trunks, are often overlooked. If we’d just pause a moment toconsider the scientific reason for their existence, we might discover new reasons to praise our Creator.

Trees are round primarily because the wood layers grow outward from the center in all directions. Growing in the shape of a cylinder has a big benefit. It seems to be optimum for tree strength against stress on the top of the tree from wind and heavy branches.

A rounded tree bends more easily than a flat-sided tree. A cylinder bends equally in all directions, depending on the wind. In contrast, a square tree trunk would be vulnerable at its corners. The corners would not bend but simply break in heavy winds. Telephone poles and light posts are round for a reason (see experiment)!

Room for Improvement?

The rounded tree shape has other benefits, too. For instance, it minimizes the outside surface exposure to injury or infestation. Round trees have one disadvantage, however—not for the trees but for modern loggers. The problem is waste.

When circular trees are harvested and cut into boards, the outer, rounded portion—nearly half of the log—ends up as scrap, whether discarded, burned, or ground into pulp for paper production. A lot of good wood is lost in the process. It has been suggested that if trees were square instead of round, there would be much less waste.

This isn’t a problem with the original tree design, however. Throughout history, logs have been a primary source of fuel, and fuel is not a waste. Only when modern industry developed other energy sources did it become “waste” to burn wood byproducts. Advanced industrial nations try to maximize their profits when harvesting trees.

Still, is there any hope of solving the waste problem? In the 1980s a botanist in Canada’s heavily forested province of British Columbia thought he might have found a way to get trees to grow square trunks. Cutting away the bark at four “corners” (every 90°) he was able to get the wood to grow extra at these corners. Carrying the idea even further, he suggested workers might be able to cut open such trees and remove flat boards from the inside. If loggers left intact the trees’ outer growth layer (called the cambium), the trees would grow new wood.

The researcher was granted a patent for his square-tree technique; however, the novel idea failed to generate commercial interest. He only succeeded in making square trees less than a centimeter across before dropping the research.

Square trees do grow in places other than research labs and storybooks. Panama is home to a grove of more-or-less square trees in the cottonwood family (Quararibea asterolepis) that has become a tourist attraction. Even the inside tree rings show the square growth pattern. But it’s just an oddity that puzzles scientists. To figure out whether the square design is caused by the environment or genetics, botanists planted some of the seedlings in Florida, where they grew normally. So it appears that the rich volcanic soil at this location in Panama may be a factor.

Trees are arguably the largest and the oldest living things on earth. One giant redwood in the western United States has grown to a height of 379 feet (115.5 m), equal to a 30-story building. Meanwhile, bristlecone pine trees live for several thousand years. Trees stand tall with outstretched arms, through storms and drought, wind and hail, summer and winter. Their round trunks clearly hold them up quite well.

See for Yourself . . .

Let’s explore the design of trees by comparing two paper shapes, round and square.

Materials

  • An 8½ x 11 inch sheet of paper
  • Tape
  • Several lightweight books (Paperbacks work well)

Procedure

To begin, fold and carefully tear in half the sheet of paper to make two equal half sheets, each 5½ x 8½ inches. Roll one sheet into a cylinder with a bit of overlap and tape the length of the seam so that the tube stands 5½ inches high. It may take a helping hand to cover the seam with tape. On the second sheet of paper, make four equal folds to form the sides of a box. Tape the seam as before, which this time will be on a corner. The result is an open rectangle the same height as the cylinder. Crease the corners of the square so they are as sharp as possible.

Now the comparison begins. Which shape, round or square, will support the most weight before collapsing? First, with the square shape standing on end, carefully place a small book on top, and then add others. The limit is typically 2-3 books before the tower collapses. The flat sides and corners appear to be the weak parts of the box shape. Next, repeat the process by stacking the same books on the round tube. You may need additional books this time. Did you find that the round shape supports more weight than the box? With no weak corners or flat sides, the cylinder has added strength.

Which paper shape, square or round, most resembles the trunk and limbs of a tree? Can you think of other rounded shapes in nature? Consider flower stems, seashells, and even our bones. Round shapes are also found around the house, including water pipes, soup cans, and light bulbs. All are designed for strength, just as God designed trees for their beauty and strength during Creation Week.

Dr. Don DeYoung is chairman of science and math at Grace College, Winona Lake, Indiana. He is an active speaker for AiG and has written 20 books on Bible-science topics. Dr. DeYoung is currently president of the Creation Research Society with hundreds of members worldwide. His website is DiscoveryofDesign.com.

Answers Magazine

January–March 2016

Discover the role of ancient Near Eastern writings in understanding Scripture and learn about some exotic animals that can only be explained by a Creator.

Browse Issue Subscribe

Newsletter

Get the latest answers emailed to you or sign up for our free print newsletter.

Answers in Genesis is an apologetics ministry, dedicated to helping Christians defend their faith and proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ.

Learn more

  • Customer Service 800.778.3390